Women’s Representation in Local Government: Breaking Barriers in the 2025 Elections

The Northern Ireland Protocol: Ongoing Tensions and Possible Solutions Post-Brexit

Table of Contents:

1. Introduction

   • Background of the Northern Ireland Protocol
   • The Significance of the Protocol in Post-Brexit Relations

2. The Origins of the Northern Ireland Protocol

   • The Brexit Negotiations and the Need for a Solution
   • The Role of the Good Friday Agreement
   • Why Northern Ireland Was Treated Differently

3. Key Provisions of the Northern Ireland Protocol

   • The Customs and Regulatory Border in the Irish Sea
   • Northern Ireland’s Continued Alignment with EU Rules
   • The Role of the European Court of Justice (ECJ)
   • The Impact on Trade Between Great Britain and Northern Ireland

4. Ongoing Tensions and Challenges

   • Economic Impact on Northern Ireland
   • Political Tensions: Unionist and Nationalist Perspectives
   • Border Checks and Supply Chain Disruptions
   • The Northern Ireland Assembly and Devolution Crisis

5. Key Stakeholders and Their Positions

   • The UK Government’s Stance and Demands for Reform
   • The EU’s Position on the Protocol
   • Northern Ireland’s Political Parties: The Unionists vs. Nationalists
   • The Role of the US and International Community

6. Possible Solutions and Alternatives

   • The “Swiss Model” and Other Models of Trade
   • Border Control Adjustments: Trust but Verify
   • A Comprehensive UK-EU Agreement on Goods and Services
   • Technological Solutions: The Role of Digital Customs

7. The Future of Northern Ireland’s Relationship with the UK and the EU

   • Managing Northern Ireland’s Dual Status
   • The Possible Path to a Reformed Protocol
   • Maintaining Stability and Peace in Northern Ireland

8. Conclusion

   • The Need for Compromise and Cooperation
   • What Lies Ahead: A Balanced Approach to Solving the Protocol Crisis

---

1. Introduction

The Northern Ireland Protocol remains one of the most contentious and unresolved aspects of the UK-EU relationship in the aftermath of Brexit. The protocol was designed as part of the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement to avoid a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, ensuring the preservation of the Good Friday Agreement. However, since its implementation, the protocol has sparked economic, political, and social tensions. This article examines the ongoing issues surrounding the Northern Ireland Protocol and explores potential solutions to ease the tensions between the UK and EU, as well as within Northern Ireland itself.

2. The Origins of the Northern Ireland Protocol

The Brexit Negotiations and the Need for a Solution

The Northern Ireland Protocol was negotiated as part of the broader Brexit deal, aiming to address the complex issue of how to manage the border between Northern Ireland (part of the UK) and the Republic of Ireland (an EU member state) after the UK left the EU. Brexit created a unique situation where Northern Ireland, though part of the UK, would need to comply with certain EU regulations to maintain the open border with the Republic of Ireland that was integral to the Good Friday Agreement (1998), which helped end decades of conflict.

The Role of the Good Friday Agreement

The Good Friday Agreement was a landmark peace agreement signed in 1998 that brought an end to the Troubles, a violent conflict between nationalists (who wanted Northern Ireland to join the Republic of Ireland) and unionists (who wanted Northern Ireland to remain part of the UK). The agreement was based on the principle of peaceful cooperation, which included the promise of an invisible border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, making the issue of a hard border critical to maintaining peace.

Why Northern Ireland Was Treated Differently

As part of the Brexit deal, Northern Ireland was given special treatment compared to the rest of the UK. While Great Britain (England, Scotland, and Wales) left the EU’s single market and customs union, Northern Ireland was required to stay aligned with some EU rules to avoid a hard border. This created the Irish Sea border, meaning that customs checks are now required on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland.

3. Key Provisions of the Northern Ireland Protocol

The Customs and Regulatory Border in the Irish Sea

The Irish Sea border introduced by the protocol means that goods coming from Great Britain to Northern Ireland are subject to customs checks and regulatory controls. The protocol essentially keeps Northern Ireland in the EU’s single market for goods, but not services, meaning that Northern Ireland follows EU rules on product standards and customs, while Great Britain does not.

Northern Ireland’s Continued Alignment with EU Rules

One of the central features of the Northern Ireland Protocol is that Northern Ireland remains aligned with many EU laws, including those governing product standards and agricultural regulations. This was seen as the best way to avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland and ensure that there were no customs checks between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. However, this arrangement has meant that Northern Ireland effectively continues to follow EU regulations without having a say in the rules, creating a sense of unequal treatment for unionists who want Northern Ireland to fully align with the rest of the UK.

The Role of the European Court of Justice (ECJ)

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) retains a role in overseeing aspects of the protocol, especially related to disputes over EU regulations. This has been a source of concern for unionists, who see the ECJ’s involvement as an infringement on the sovereignty of the UK and Northern Ireland.

The Impact on Trade Between Great Britain and Northern Ireland

The new customs checks have caused delays and disruptions in trade between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Businesses in Northern Ireland have faced increased costs, and goods have sometimes been delayed or rejected. Some goods that would have previously traveled freely across the Irish Sea are now subject to customs procedures, creating friction in what was once a seamless internal UK market.

4. Ongoing Tensions and Challenges

Economic Impact on Northern Ireland

The protocol has had a mixed economic impact. While Northern Ireland has benefited from continued access to the EU market for goods, businesses have faced increased costs and bureaucratic hurdles when trading with Great Britain. Local businesses that depended on smooth trade with the rest of the UK have been particularly affected by the administrative burden and costs of complying with the new customs procedures.

Political Tensions: Unionist and Nationalist Perspectives

The protocol has caused significant political division within Northern Ireland. Unionists, who are generally supportive of Northern Ireland’s status as part of the UK, view the protocol as a betrayal and a threat to Northern Ireland’s position within the UK. They argue that the protocol creates an economic and political divide between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK, effectively placing a border in the Irish Sea.

Nationalists, on the other hand, argue that the protocol provides a unique opportunity for Northern Ireland to benefit from both the UK and EU markets, strengthening its relationship with the Republic of Ireland and its role within the EU’s single market. However, even some nationalists feel uncomfortable with the protocol’s implications for the democratic representation of Northern Ireland in UK affairs.

Border Checks and Supply Chain Disruptions

Since the implementation of the protocol, border checks have caused significant supply chain disruptions, particularly for perishable goods like food and agricultural products. The impact of these delays has been felt across the grocery sector, where businesses are experiencing increased costs and stock shortages.

The Northern Ireland Assembly and Devolution Crisis

The tensions caused by the protocol have led to political instability in the Northern Ireland Assembly. The Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) and other unionist parties have repeatedly criticized the protocol and called for its revision or abolition, while the Sinn Féin party, which supports Irish nationalism, has been more accepting of the protocol. The dispute over the protocol has added to existing challenges in the Northern Ireland power-sharing arrangement, causing difficulties in governance.

5. Key Stakeholders and Their Positions

The UK Government’s Stance and Demands for Reform

The UK government has repeatedly called for changes to the protocol, citing the economic damage and political unrest it has caused. The UK’s demand for reform primarily focuses on removing the role of the ECJ in overseeing the protocol and seeking to simplify customs procedures to reduce disruption in trade between Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

The EU’s Position on the Protocol

The EU has consistently defended the protocol as a necessary compromise to protect the integrity of the EU’s single market and preserve the Good Friday Agreement. However, it has also shown a willingness to consider adjustments to the protocol to address practical challenges, provided they do not undermine the EU’s regulatory framework.

Northern Ireland’s Political Parties: The Unionists vs. Nationalists

The unionist parties, such as the DUP, view the protocol as an affront to Northern Ireland’s constitutional status within the UK and have pushed for its removal or drastic modification. On the other hand, nationalist parties like Sinn Féin see the protocol as a means of maintaining Northern Ireland’s economic and political links with the EU, which they believe strengthens its relationship with the Republic of Ireland.

The Role of the US and International Community

The United States has been involved in the debate, with President Joe Biden’s administration expressing concern about the potential for the protocol to undermine the peace process in Northern Ireland. The US

has called for pragmatic solutions that respect both the Good Friday Agreement and the UK’s sovereignty.

6. Possible Solutions and Alternatives

The “Swiss Model” and Other Models of Trade

One possible solution involves adopting a model similar to the Swiss model, where the UK and the EU have a series of bilateral agreements covering specific areas like trade and regulatory alignment. This would allow for more flexible arrangements without the need for a hard border.

Border Control Adjustments: Trust but Verify

Another possible solution is streamlining border controls and moving toward a "trusted trader" system, where businesses with a proven record could benefit from simplified procedures and fewer checks.

A Comprehensive UK-EU Agreement on Goods and Services

A broader UK-EU agreement that addresses goods and services, alongside Northern Ireland’s specific needs, could create a comprehensive framework that balances both EU regulations and the UK’s internal market.

Technological Solutions: The Role of Digital Customs

Technological solutions, such as digital customs systems and smart border technologies, could help alleviate some of the practical challenges of border checks. These technologies could allow for more efficient trade without compromising the integrity of the EU’s single market or the UK’s regulatory independence.

7. The Future of Northern Ireland’s Relationship with the UK and the EU

The future of Northern Ireland will likely hinge on finding a solution that balances the interests of both the UK and the EU, as well as those of Northern Ireland’s unionists and nationalists. Whether this involves reformulating the protocol or adopting new models of cooperation, maintaining peace and political stability in Northern Ireland will remain a critical priority.

8. Conclusion

The Northern Ireland Protocol represents one of the most significant and sensitive issues in post-Brexit relations. The ongoing tensions and challenges are a reflection of the difficulty in balancing economic, political, and cultural interests. A lasting solution will require compromise, cooperation, and creativity, ensuring that the interests of all stakeholders, including Northern Ireland’s unique position, are respected. The future of the Northern Ireland Protocol will shape the region's relationship with both the UK and the EU for years to come.